So when I posted about the Cast Away Collection from Sinful Colors, I let you know this was coming. Normally I don’t have to compare colors that are all in the SAME collection, but this was pretty neccessary no? They are really close! I thought a look at all 3 side by side would help show differences.

In the bottle, Greek Isles & Be Happy are super close. I honestly double checked to make sure that I didn’t have two of the same shade before I left the store! They have a few differences though, which I outlined when I did the bottle shots in the prior post. Still though, to be in the same collection, I think they should have done something a little different with those two. Athens is different enough for me in the bottle & definitely different on the nail! In fact, I love Athens.

  Pointer- Be Happy   Middle-Greek Isles   Ring- Athens

  Pointer- Be Happy   Middle-Greek Isles   Ring- Athens

 Pointer- Be Happy   Middle-Greek Isles   Ring- Athens

On the nail, these 3 shades are very different…luckily.Be Happy is clearly a shade or two lighter, but honestly most people probably won’t need Be Happy & Greek Isles. Athens is a gorgeous murky shade I love that definitely plays more on the green side of the spectrum. These are all 2 medium coats with no top coat. Nice shine right?